Financial Sense   Home  l  Broadcast  l  WrapUp  l  Storm Watch  l  About Us  l  Contact Us

THE CASE FOR INVESTING IN 
WATER INDUSTRY STOCKS
~
2006 Update ~
by John Dickerson, President & CEO
Summit Global Management, Inc.
January 27, 2006

Foreword
Water is by far the most common substance on earth, yet it is in exceedingly short supply. We cannot create water, yet it is infinitely renewable. Water is stupendously under-priced, yet it is the most valuable substance that exists. Water is commonly abused, yet it cannot be destroyed. Water is the only substance that can be a liquid, a solid or a gas: We can change its form, but we cannot duplicate its substance. The supply of water is forever fixed, yet our supplies are diminishing very rapidly. While abusively under-valued, water has no substitute regardless of price, the only element in the world of which this is true: This most fundaments of facts creates the inexorable and intractable demand for water that will not abate with time.

A Compelling Investment Theme

The water industry is comprised of a vast array of companies providing products and services toward the collection, conveyance, treatment and monitoring/analysis of water and wastewater for multiple purposes and end users. As you will see in the table below, investing in the U.S.-based utility component of this industry has historically worked very well, but the time has come for much broader global exposure in water stocks.

Water is the single most important economic input to the global economy, and more specifically, to individual enterprises. The disparity between supply and demand for clean water is an inexorable problem; yet the relentless demographic demand for its uninterrupted supply makes water by far the most stable of all commodities – unaffected by cyclical influences which constantly badger other more typical input commodities.

This global theme of water insufficiency relative to unrelenting demand, along with all the related trends and opportunities it has spawned, continues to benefit the prospects of a broad range of publicly traded companies which help to provide solutions to this supply/demand dilemma.. A diverse global universe of investment opportunities exists within the theme of water investing; all the while eliminating the typical resistance to sector fund investments, which are far more limited in scope and susceptible to cyclical influences: Water investing is a broad and deep global theme, and is far too diverse to be considered sector investing.


Water Utilities: The Industry Stalwart

U.S. water utilities have generally been the largest core investment group for most water investment portfolios, for the simple reason that U.S. water utilities have been a leading stock market performer for many years. Moreover, dividends have played a large part in these total return figures, which tends to dampen market volatility for these shares.

5 Year Summary-12/31/00 to 12/31/-5

Total Ret Annual
 Water Utility Stocks* 134.57%   19.59%  
 S&P 500 Index TR 2.74%   0.54%  
 Dow Jones Industrial Average TR 10.42%   2.00%  
 NASDAQ Composite Index -8.47%   -1.75%  

10 Year Summary-12/31/00 to 12/31/05

Total Ret Annual
 Water Utility Stocks* 446.01%   18.50%  
 S&P 500 Index TR 138.29%   9.06%  
 Dow Jones Industrial Average TR 154.69%   9.79%  
 NASDAQ Composite Index 118.29%   8.11%  

 Source: Bloomberg Analytics

*An equally-weighted list of all publicly traded U.S. water utility stocks that existed as of 12/31/05. Importantly, this is a negatively-selected list, in that some public water utility stocks were acquired during the years depicted above, and the returns on those acquired companies, normally purchased at large premiums to market prices, are not included herein. Thus, if this compilation included the returns of all water utility stocks that were trading at the beginning of these periods, the returns would have been substantially higher.

A striking and very illustrative fact is that we have found that in any randomly selected five-year period in the last 25 years (1982-87, 1993-98, 1979-84, etc.) water utilities usually topped the list of the best performing industry groups in the U.S. stock market on a total return basis. Why? The simple answer is that water utilities have always done very well in good times and bad. When compared to any other industry, water utilities have a more obvious and compelling business model with the most persistent demand and probably the most predictable future.

In addition, regular dividend increases tend to keep the stock prices moving ahead on a very consistent and predictable basis. Such regular dividend increases are a hallmark of the water utility group, and are perhaps the best indicator of the quality and stability of any enterprise. It also says a lot about the cash generated by these businesses.

Aqua America (WTR), formerly known as Philadelphia Suburban Corporation, is presently the largest investor-owned American water utility in the US. Its dividend history is not only impressive, but also quite instructive. In November of 2005, the company announced a 10% dividend increase and a 4 for 3 stock split, which represents the 15th increase in 14 years. The company has paid dividends since 1945. The March 1, 2005, payment began the 60th consecutive year of shareholder dividend payments. This stellar record led the company to the number one spot in the performance list below.

Similarly, late in 2005, Southwest Water Company (SWWC), another American water utility, announced a 10% increase in its quarterly dividend and a 5% stock dividend payable in January of 2006. This is the kind of news that Southwest Water investors have regularly enjoyed, and helps to explain why Southwest is second in the 10-year performance list below.

The long-term total return of water utilities continued to be a leader in the U.S. stock market through 2005. Below is a list comparing the ten remaining investor-owned water utilities in the U.S. as compared to a list of popular investment icons.

Keep in mind that this utility list used to be much longer, but many companies beyond the ten now remaining were bought by water-savvy foreign investors over the last ten years, and the list is now much reduced. Thus, the current list is somewhat negatively selected, in that many of the better-performing companies are no longer part of the group and some of the laggards remain.

The following table illustrates a list of widely held American stocks for the most recent 10-year period (12/31/1995 through 12/31/2005).

 

 

1995 - 2005

Symbol

Name

Total Return

Annualized

WTR

Aqua America Inc

818.50%

24.80%

SWWC

Southwest Water Co.

765.72%

24.09%

SJW

SJW Corp.

412.42%

17.75%

ARTNA

Artesian Resources

411.60%

17.73%

AXP

Amer Express

370.02%

16.72%

YORW

York Water Co.

354.07%

16.34%

WMT

Walmart Stores

351.14%

16.24%

PNNW

Pennichuck Corp.

332.82%

15.78%

HD

Home Depot

302.88%

14.93%

IBM

Intl Bus Mach.

286.71%

14.47%

CWT

California Water Serv

259.59%

13.65%

XOM

Exxon Mobil Corp

257.81%

13.58%

GE

Gen Electric

255.09%

13.49%

AWR

American States Water

248.79%

13.31%

PG

Procter & Gamble

235.15%

12.84%

JNJ

Johnson & Johnson

227.29%

12.57%

CTWS

Connecticut Water Serv

202.07%

11.69%

MSEX

Middlesex Water Co.

196.09%

11.47%

INDU

Dow Jones Indus Avg.

154.69%

9.79%

SPX

S&P 500 Index

138.29%

9.06%

CCMP

Nasdaq Composi

118.29%

8.11%

MCD

McDonalds Corp

65.80%

5.18%

K

Kellogg Co.

47.73%

3.97%

DIS

Disney Co.

32.86%

2.88%

MRK

Merck & Co.

31.70%

2.79%

KO

Coca-Cola Co.

26.35%

2.36%

Source: Bloomberg Analytics - All returns are with dividends reinvested.


The Water Industry - An Extensive and Diverse Global Universe of Companies

We have discussed water utilities up to this point, but it must be strongly emphasized that water utilities are actually only a small part of our investment universe of global water industry stocks. Indeed, the Summit-defined water stock universe stood at 359 companies on 12/31/05, and less than 20% of the list was water utilities. Our emphasis in discussing water utilities was intended to illustrate the remarkable stability at the basic delivery point of the industry, and how all companies participating in the industry’s supply and service chain are very positively influenced by this persistency and stability.

Summary by Region – December 2005

 

Total

# of

Median 

 Median 

Median

Median 

Median 

Median 

Median 

Median 

Region

Mkt Cap USD

Comps

P/E

EV/EBITDA

P/S

P/B

D/E

Div Yld

ROE

ROE 5YR

Asia & Pacific Rim

$84,912,970,957 

143

18.71 

12.17 

1.03 

1.43 

35.80%

1.44%

7.97%

5.95%

Europe & Africa

$327,259,473,004 

95

19.82 

8.91 

1.08 

2.46 

61.45%

2.67%

9.93%

9.95%

Latin America & Canada

$21,954,702,028 

18

13.51 

10.42 

2.41 

1.60 

43.73%

3.13%

9.22%

7.98%

United States

$226,907,053,970 

103

22.21 

10.12 

1.09 

2.37 

46.62%

0.62%

9.69%

9.79%

Total

$661,034,199,959 

359

19.26 

10.27 

1.08 

1.99 

45.17%

2.06%

9.46%

8.89%

The non-utility majority of companies on our list are basic water industrial stocks: Companies involved with pumps, pipes, valves, filters, testing, instrumentation, engineering, and construction of water systems. Water utilities are the highly visible point of the spear in the water industry, but the water industrials are the shaft of that spear, and one cannot be effective without the other.

Notice that only 103 of the 359 companies in the chart above are U.S. companies: This is truly a global industry, although it has not been perceived as such by most investors. The over-emphasis on U.S. companies is pointed out by the statistics within the above summary: Note that the valuation numbers for U.S. water equities are well above, while the dividends are well below, those of the rest of the world. We believe that these disparities will be removed by global markets in due course.

As we said earlier, less than 10% of the customers in the U.S. are served by an investor-owned utility, and that number is probably also around 10% on a global basis. However, every water utility, whether owned by a municipality or stockholders, must buy the goods and services necessary to provide uninterrupted service and to provide a regulatory compliant product. Every water utility is a steady customer of the water industrials, and obviously the services of the utility must remain uninterrupted. Therefore, the business order flow to the industrials also has a stable and non-cyclical quality. Indeed, there is a pronounced “trickle-down” effect in the water industry, and that is not just a play on words.

Over the last 25 years, we have found that companies who sell mainly to water utilities have a much more persistent, predictable, and stable business profile than those similar companies who might be selling into more cyclical industries. Thus, a valve maker selling to water utilities is likely to have a much better business than a valve maker selling to the oil industry or to the aircraft industry. Here again, many segments of the water industrial sector are highly localized and fragmented and offer fertile prospects for the benefits of consolidation and privatization.


Water: The Ultimate Supply vs. Demand Story

We have exactly the same amount of water in our ecosystem today as we had 10 million years ago. The difference between then and now is that there are now some 6 billion people competing for this increasingly scarce resource, the supply of which cannot be increased along with population increases. Indeed, global per-capital water supplies do not just decline annually on an arithmetic basis, equivalent to the 2% global population growth, but rather on a geometric basis, which results from these same 6 billion people polluting the increasingly scarce remaining supplies of potable fresh water.

The table below outlines how very rare is the usable supply of fresh water available for human use. Indeed, this number is just a very small fraction of 1% of all the water on the planet, and on a per-capita basis, this supply is declining at an alarming rate.

When considering water supplies, a common error is often made in considering only that amount of daily water that is needed for consumption by each person on earth. But while water is the most basic of human needs for survival, it is followed closely by the need for food, and the most vital input to sustain world food supplies is adequate water resources, which is the key to all world food production.

Taking a moment to consider the table below will help put the water supply and demand equation is some perspective:

Water Source

Water Volume in Cubic Miles

Percent of Total Water

Oceans

317,000,000

97.24%

Icecaps, Glaciers

7,000,000

2.14%

Ground Water

2,000,000

0.61%

Fresh-Water Lakes

30,000

0.009%

Inland Seas

25,000

0.008%

Soil Moisture

16,000

0.005%

Atmosphere

3,100