In a recent interview on the Financial Sense Newshour, Chris Puplava, Chief Investment Officer at Financial Sense Wealth Management, provided a comprehensive analysis of current economic trends and their potential implications for the future. Puplava suggests that despite market optimism, several key indicators point to further economic trouble ahead, including potential risk of recession.
Podcast audio: Smart Macro: Are Investors Too Optimistic About the Outlook?
Mixed Signals and Federal Reserve Shift
Puplava began by noting the mixed messages in the U.S. economy, with manufacturing still in recession since 2022 and the services sector barely expanding. He highlighted a significant shift in the Federal Reserve's communication at their recent Jackson Hole meeting where Powell now sees less risks from inflation and more risk to the job market moving forward. This change in perspective has led to 100% odds of rate cuts at the Fed’s next meeting on September 18th, according to the futures market.
Powell: “My confidence has grown that inflation is on a sustainable path back to 2 percent…[but] downside risks to employment have increased…[and] the time has come for policy to adjust.” [Full transcript]
Key Economic Indicators
Several economic indicators discussed by Puplava paint a concerning picture:
Housing Market: Pending home sales hit a record low, indicating no turnaround in the housing sector due to high prices and elevated interest rates.
Employment: Continuing jobless claims are at a two to three-year high, showing a rising trend since mid-2022.
Manufacturing: Regional Fed manufacturing surveys, which cover the entire United States, consistently show manufacturing in recession since mid-2022.
Services Sector: The ISM Services index is currently showing very weak growth, posting a reading of 51.5 for August (anything above 50 represents growth and below 50 represents contraction).
Economic Surprise Index: The Citigroup Economic Surprise Index, which measures actual economic results against forecasts, has been consistently negative since May, suggesting economists are too optimistic in their projections.
Soft Landing vs. Hard Landing
Puplava emphasized that the critical question for investors is whether the economy will experience a soft landing or a hard landing (recession). Historically, when the Federal Reserve starts easing monetary policy, stock markets tend to accelerate if a soft landing occurs. However, if rate cuts are in response to an impending recession, market performance is typically less robust.
Based on historical data, Puplava estimates a 90% probability of a hard landing (recession) versus a 10% chance of a soft landing. He supports this view with several key points:
Magnitude of Expected Rate Cuts: The market is forecasting 8-9 rate cuts (over 200 basis points) by the end of 2025. Historically, such significant easing cycles have almost always been associated with recessions.
Lag in Monetary Policy Impact: There's typically a two-year lag between interest rate changes and their effect on the economy, suggesting that the full impact of recent rate hikes is yet to be felt.
Unemployment Rate Projections: Historical patterns indicate that the unemployment rate is likely to continue rising throughout 2024 and beyond, based on the lag effect of interest rate hikes (Fed funds rate shifted forward by 2 years in chart above to show lead-lag relationship over past 50 years).
Historical Precedent: Out of eight instances since 1970 where the Federal Reserve cut rates by more than 200 basis points, seven resulted in recessions.
Significant Job Data Revision: A substantial downward revision of 818,000 jobs in the non-farm payrolls number for March 2023 to March 2024 indicates that previous job creation estimates were overly optimistic.
Market Implications
Puplava expressed concern about the current market valuation, noting that with the Dow Jones Industrial Average over 41,000 and the S&P 500 near all-time highs, there appears to be no recession risk priced into the market. This discrepancy between economic indicators and market valuations presents both risks and opportunities for investors.
Investment Strategy
Given these economic signals, Puplava outlined his investment approach:
- Neutral Stance: Maintaining a neutral outlook, neither aggressively bullish nor bearish.
- Prepared for Quick Action: Ready to shift to a defensive position if warranted by further economic deterioration.
- Focus on Mispriced Risk: Identifying opportunities where the market has not adequately priced in recession risk.
Fiscal Policy Considerations
Puplava also touched on the role of fiscal policy, noting that increased fiscal stimulus in late 2022 and early 2023 likely prevented an official recession. However, with the upcoming election and increased partisanship, he expects less fiscal support going forward, potentially exacerbating economic challenges.
Conclusion
While the stock market remains near all-time highs, Chris Puplava's analysis suggests that investors should be cautious. Multiple economic indicators, historical patterns, and the anticipated impact of past monetary policy decisions point to a higher probability of a recession in the near future. The discrepancy between these economic signals and current market valuations presents both risks and potential opportunities for informed investors.
Puplava advises a balanced approach, maintaining a neutral stance while being prepared to quickly adopt a more defensive position if economic conditions continue to deteriorate. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing and acting on mispriced risk in the market, as this is where significant returns can be generated.
As the economic landscape continues to evolve, investors would do well to closely monitor these key indicators and be prepared for potential market volatility. The coming months may prove critical in determining whether the economy achieves a soft landing or enters a more challenging recessionary period.
To speak with any of our advisors or wealth managers, feel free to Contact Us or give us a call at (888) 486-3939.
To listen to this podcast conversation, see Smart Macro: Are Investors Too Optimistic About the Outlook? for audio.
For a link to our full podcast archive, see Financial Sense Newshour (All) and don't forget to subscribe on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or Google Podcasts!
Advisory services offered through Financial Sense® Advisors, Inc., a registered investment adviser. Securities offered through Financial Sense® Securities, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC. DBA Financial Sense® Wealth Management. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principle. Past performance is not indicative of future results. This material has been provided for informational purposes only.
