Amid all the media hyperbole around record share buybacks the past few years, very few people seem to grasp the net effect. A new must read report “Are Buybacks an Oasis or a Mirage” lays out the math for those wanting to see.
The bottom line: the dominant motivation of buybacks has been to enable executive cash outs at the expense of the company’s health, its employees, creditors and shareholders. To wit:
When management redeems stock options, new shares are issued to them, diluting other shareholders. A buyback is then announced that roughly matches the size of the option redemption. This facilitates management’s resale of the new stock they were issued in the option redemption. Buyback? Not really! Management compensation? Yes.
Because the stock options a company issues its management dilute the value of its stockholders’ shares, companies often repurchase their stock to offset this dilutive effect. The net impact is a transfer to management of more of a company’s cash flow than is reported as compensation on the income statement. Irrespective of the intent of the company to reduce the dilutive impact of its options-based stock issuance with buybacks, the reality is that the dilution is not always totally offset…often a company’s repurchase of its stock was accompanied by a net increase in debt.
…The reality is that publicly traded companies in the United States are issuing far more new securities than they are buying back, diluting existing investors’ ownership and reducing growth in earnings and dividends per share well below the growth of their reported profits. There is, in fact, no net transfer of cash from the coffers of US corporations to the wallets of US equity investors. The buyback oasis evaporates as we approach it. For investors in the aggregate US public equity market, buybacks are simply a mirage.
Investors have not been complaining about share buybacks because as corporate revenues have weakened, buybacks and dividend payments helped to placate shareholders with increased earnings per share and rising share prices. Once shares begin to fall however, holders soon discover that the appearance of gain is fleeting. In reality corporate executives have ‘cashed out’ mind-boggling sums for themselves, while leaving shareholders and creditors holding risky paper in a much degraded enterprise.
Related:
The Truths and Myths of Buybacks
